Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. I may earn a commission if you click through and subscribe, at no extra cost to you.
Every serious writer uses a grammar and style checker. The question is which one. Grammarly is the household name — everyone knows it. ProWritingAid is the specialist’s choice. They cost similar amounts but serve different writing philosophies.
Here’s the honest comparison after using both for professional client work.
Quick Comparison
| Grammarly | ProWritingAid | |
|---|---|---|
| Price (annual) | $144/year | $120/year |
| Free plan | ✅ Generous | ✅ Limited |
| Best for | Real-time writing | Deep manuscript editing |
| Plagiarism checker | ✅ Premium | ✅ Premium |
| Style reports | Basic | 25+ detailed reports |
| Integration | Everywhere | Most major platforms |
| Affiliate commission | $20/premium signup | 40% per sale |
Grammarly: What It Does Best
Real-Time Editing Everywhere
Grammarly’s browser extension works in virtually every text field on the web — Gmail, Google Docs, WordPress, Slack, LinkedIn, Twitter, and hundreds of other platforms. For writers who work across multiple tools, this ubiquity is Grammarly’s greatest strength. The corrections appear as you type, with no copy-paste workflow required.
Tone Detector
Grammarly’s tone detector analyzes your writing and tells you how it comes across — confident, formal, friendly, direct, etc. For freelancers writing in different voices for different clients, this is a useful calibration tool.
Ease of Use
Grammarly is the most frictionless editing tool available. Install it once and it works everywhere automatically. For writers who want corrections without disrupting their workflow, nothing is simpler.
ProWritingAid: What It Does Best
Depth of Analysis
ProWritingAid offers 25+ detailed writing reports covering everything from overused words and sentence length variation to pacing, dialogue tags, and clichés. For writers who want to genuinely improve their craft — not just fix errors — this depth is unmatched at any price point.
Fiction Writing Support
ProWritingAid has specific features built for fiction writers: manuscript reports, chapter-by-chapter analysis, dialogue pacing, and consistency checking for character names and settings. Grammarly treats all writing the same — ProWritingAid understands the difference between a business email and a novel chapter.
Price
At $120/year vs Grammarly’s $144/year, ProWritingAid is cheaper on the annual plan. It also offers a one-time lifetime license for around $399 — no subscription, ever. For writers who plan to use an editing tool for years, the lifetime option makes ProWritingAid significantly more economical long-term.
Where Each Falls Short
Grammarly’s weakness: Surface-level suggestions. Grammarly catches errors but doesn’t help you become a better writer. Its suggestions are often overly cautious, flagging stylistic choices as errors. Writers with a strong voice often find Grammarly’s recommendations homogenizing.
ProWritingAid’s weakness: It requires a dedicated editing session — you can’t just write and have it correct in real time as naturally as Grammarly. The interface is more complex and takes time to learn. For quick emails and short-form web writing, ProWritingAid is overkill.
Which Should You Choose?
Choose Grammarly if: You write across many different platforms and want real-time corrections everywhere, you produce mostly short-form content (emails, social, copy), or you want the simplest possible setup with no learning curve.
Choose ProWritingAid if: You write long-form content — articles, reports, books — and want deep analysis beyond error-checking, you write fiction, or you’re cost-conscious and want the lifetime license option.
Use both if: Use Grammarly free as your always-on real-time checker, and ProWritingAid for dedicated editing passes on important long-form work. This combination covers every scenario at minimal cost.
Final Verdict
Grammarly is the better tool for everyday writing across multiple platforms. ProWritingAid is the better tool for serious long-form editing and craft improvement. They’re not really competing — they serve different moments in the writing process.
If you can only choose one: use Grammarly free as your baseline, and invest in ProWritingAid Premium when you’re ready to take your writing quality seriously. That’s the honest recommendation.